Fundamentally Speaking

Ending Soybean Stockpiles Overstated for Past 25 Years

Joel Karlin
By  Joel Karlin , DTN Contributing Analyst

Similar to what we did with corn, this graphic shows the change in U.S. soybean ending stocks from the first WASDE report given in May to the final one for each marketing year furnished in November the following year plotted on the right hand axis in million bushels.

To answer why the stocks estimate was different we also plot the 18-month change in the production, crush and exports on the left hand axis also in million bushels.

One of the first observations is how the USDA has consistently overstated final U.S. soybean ending stocks from the initial WASDE estimate including nine years in a row from 1994 to 2003, 12 out of 14 years from 1991 to 2003, 14 of 16 years from 1995 to 2011 and 9 of 10 years from 2007 to 2017.

Looking at the individual correlations it appears that production less than had originally been projected is the biggest reason why stocks end up lower with a 44.3% correlation rate.

We had long suspected that the USDA understating overseas demand was often the reason why the final carryout figure was lower than the projection made 18 months earlier but the correlation here was just 28.4% with the correlation between the change in the crush estimate and stocks a mere 10.6%.

Note that the standard deviation of production shows this component is the most volatile of all four variables being output, the amount of soybeans that are processed, the amount exported and the amount left over at the end of the marketing years.

Finally, though the 2017/18 figures are not yet final the last ending stocks projection for this year was put at 530 million bushels, 50 million more than first estimated in May 2017 and if this is the case come November would be the largest positive differential since the 2005/06 season.



To comment, please Log In or Join our Community .