Market Matters Blog

DDG Prices Lower On Slowing Demand, Large Supplies

Mary Kennedy
By  Mary Kennedy , DTN Basis Analyst
Connect with Mary:
DTN's average weekly spot price for DDG was down $4, at $94 per ton. (DTN file photo by Elaine Shein)

The DTN average dried distillers grains, or DDG, spot price was down $4 per ton from two weeks ago, at $94, for the week ended March 9. Of the 39 locations from which DTN collects spot prices, 27 bids ranged from $2 to $20 lower, two bids ranged from $5 to $8 higher and the balance of the prices were unchanged.

Prices moved lower the past week as supplies have become heavy and demand has slowed. One merchandiser told me that besides warm weather slowing feed use, pastures are greening and animals can be turned out to pasture to feed.

While the U.S. Energy Information Administration said ethanol plant production slowed for the week ending March 3, we will need to see more of a slowdown to keep supplies from becoming burdensome. The opening of the Mississippi River on March 9 as the first tow reached St. Paul, Minnesota, should be supportive to shippers and allow them to move more product than to just rely on trucks and rail cars, which have seen some weather-related logistic issues the past few months.

The value of DDG relative to corn for the week ended March 9 was lower at 73.16% and the value of DDG relative to soybean meal was lower at 29.00%. The cost per unit of protein for DDG was lower at $3.76 compared to the cost per unit of protein for soybean meal which was lower at $6.82. The low relative prices indicates that prices may be near the bottom, but without a rebound in exports, prices could continue to work lower.

CIF NOLA (New Orleans, Louisiana) dried distillers grains with solubles, or DDGS, prices for the week ended March 9 were down 8 cents to down 4 cents for March, at $115 to $124 per ton and down 1 cent to down 7 cents for April at $121 to $125. Export demand nearby has remained slow, but the January numbers were up compared to one year ago totaling 937,628 metric tons in January, up 17% from a year ago. The U.S. Census Bureau said Mexico was the top export destination in January, accounting for 19% of total exports, followed by Turkey and China. China's January purchase of 87,310 metric tons was down 60% from a year ago and Vietnam was notably absent.

A merchandiser told me that in early February, there was chatter back and forth between USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, or APHIS, and Vietnam's Plant Protection Department about what fumigants can be accepted for use on containers, who would monitor the fumigation in the United States, what documentation would be acceptable, along with other issues about the process from start to finish. After speaking with the rest of the industry, APHIS is expected to send a final proposal to Vietnam's PPD for approval, but so far there is no word they have done so.

One of the concerns is it may be possible a forbidden insect actually enters the DDGS container from other unrelated containers while en route to Vietnam on a ship. A merchandiser told me that U.S. shippers have told Vietnam this kind of infestation is not possible in bulk ships because they are fumigated at port and then aired out while heading to Vietnam and are not exposed to insects like containers may be. Also, fumigation of an entire ship full of DDGS is more reliable than container fumigation.

Shippers hoped this would change the PPD's mind and at least allow bulk U.S. DDGS to start shipping, but that has not yet happened. Regardless, no matter what happens between APHIS and the PPD, a merchandiser told me that none of this may be settled until summer or later.

Meanwhile, Vietnam has been buying DDGS from Canada and other countries, ignoring the U.S. that used to be their No. 1 source. On top of that, DDGS prices in Vietnam are close to $100 per ton higher than U.S. prices. That in itself makes no sense, but nothing is changing in the near future to fix it.

COMPANY STATE 3/9/2017 2/16/2017 CHANGE
Bartlett and Company, Kansas City, MO (816-753-6300)
Missouri Dry $118 $122 -$4
Modified $60 $60 $0
CHS, Minneapolis, MN (800-769-1066)
Illinois Dry $100 $100 $0
Indiana Dry $95 $100 -$5
Iowa Dry $95 $100 -$5
Michigan Dry $88 $88 $0
Minnesota Dry $90 $97 -$7
North Dakota Dry $95 $97 -$2
New York Dry $115 $115 $0
South Dakota Dry $90 $97 -$7
MGP Ingredients, Atchison, KS (800-255-0302 Ext. 5253)
Kansas Dry $105 $105 $0
POET Nutrition, Sioux Falls, SD (888-327-8799)
Indiana Dry $90 $90 $0
Iowa Dry $95 $96 -$1
Michigan Dry $90 $90 $0
Minnesota Dry $93 $95 -$2
Missouri Dry $115 $115 $0
Ohio Dry $90 $90 $0
South Dakota Dry $95 $98 -$3
United BioEnergy, Wichita, KS (316-616-3521)
Kansas Dry $102 $110 -$8
Wet $45 $50 -$5
Illinois Dry $102 $115 -$13
Nebraska Dry $102 $105 -$3
Wet $35 $40 -$5
U.S. Commodities, Minneapolis, MN (888-293-1640)
Illinois Dry $95 $95 $0
Indiana Dry $90 $90 $0
Iowa Dry $95 $95 $0
Michigan Dry $95 $90 $5
Minnesota Dry $85 $90 -$5
Nebraska Dry $90 $100 -$10
New York Dry $120 $105 $15
North Dakota Dry $100 $105 -$5
Ohio Dry $98 $90 $8
South Dakota Dry $90 $95 -$5
Wisconsin Dry $90 $95 -$5
Valero Energy Corp., San Antonio, TX (402-932-5901)
Indiana Dry $80 $100 -$20
Iowa Dry $85 $100 -$15
Minnesota Dry $80 $95 -$15
Nebraska Dry $85 $95 -$10
Ohio Dry $90 $100 -$10
South Dakota Dry $80 $90 -$10
California $150 $158 -$8
Western Milling, Goshen, California (559-302-1074)
California Dry $166 $172 -$6
*Prices listed per ton.
Weekly Average $94 $98 -$4
The weekly average prices above reflect only those companies DTN
collects spot prices from. States include: Missouri, Iowa, Nebraska,
Kansas, Illinois, Minnesota, North Dakota, South Dakota, Michigan,
Wisconsin and Indiana. Prices for Pennsylvania, New York and
California are not included in the averages.

Mary Kennedy can be reached at

Follow Mary Kennedy on Twitter @MaryCKenn



To comment, please Log In or Join our Community .