An Urban's Rural View

Trading Safety for Convenience on the Internet

Urban C Lehner
By  Urban C Lehner , Editor Emeritus
Connect with Urban:
Are we safe in a world where 21 billion "things" plus most bank accounts are attached to the internet? (DTN File Photo)

Nothing works in Internetland anymore. The parade of outages seems endless: Microsoft, the air traffic control system, Chase Manhattan, United Airlines, the NSA.

In each of these cases, the relevant authorities have assured us that cyberattacks weren't involved. Still, the public is panicking.

Fear of AI and cyberattacks and data centers is everywhere. Some people are sure the authorities are lying; some are laying in supplies of food, water and first aid equipment.

Before we embrace conspiracy theories, let's consider a couple of explanations for the parade. One is that outages happen all the time; the only thing different now is they're getting more publicity. There may be something to that, though it does seem like there are more now than usual.

The other explanation is actually AI and cyberattack related, but not the way the public thinks. It says AI has become extremely good at detecting vulnerabilities in software. When it does, the vulnerabilities must be patched before the bad guys use AI to exploit them. Patching is done by modifying code, which can sometimes lead to unexpected results that cause outages.

Call me naive, but that explanation seems plausible to me. I admit, though, that it is not a reason to feel less stressed about the possibility of cyberattacks. Sooner or later the bad guys will get there first, won't they?

And these outages aside, there's been some scary stuff going on in Internetland. In recent weeks, cyberattacks have been wreaking havoc in Europe.

P[L1] D[0x0] M[300x250] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]

In France, cyberattackers caused millions of dollars of food spoilage and some 20 fires by pushing up the temperature on 700 supermarket refrigerators. A French blood bank was attacked but caught the temperature change in time to avoid loss.

Iran appears to be responsible for what happened in France and likely also for the cyberattacks that hit municipal water systems in seven U.S. states in July. But the Iranians aren't the only hackers. Last month, North Korean hackers stole $6.3 billion from the cryptocurrency company Binance.

In the midst of all this, the leading AI firm Anthropic just launched an initial public offering of its shares while warning in the offering prospectus that its product could, if misused, pose "catastrophic or existential risks to humanity."

You know, things like launching unstoppable biological weapons or bringing down the Internet and the financial system with it. Not to mention risks less catastrophic to humanity but catastrophic to you, like draining your bank account.

Is it any wonder the public is so concerned about cyberattacks?

Meaningful regulation isn't in the cards. The Trump administration is more concerned with losing the AI race to China than the catastrophic risks. Many AI experts figure it will take a catastrophic event to occur before governments will decide to intervene.

After the attacks in France, some suggested rethinking the so-called "internet of things." Maybe, they said, we shouldn't be connecting everything to the internet. France's refrigerators wouldn't be vulnerable to hacks if they weren't controlled by the internet.

Disconnecting, though, would increase costs and slow operations, sometimes drastically. Without remote data tracking factories, trucking companies, hospitals and many other businesses would be far less efficient. By one estimate, there are 21 billion internet-connected "things" in the world already.

Many consumers use remote data tracking, too. I admit to being one of them. Thanks to the internet I can change the temperature in my house or let a workman enter while I'm away.

By connecting their things to the internet, businesses and consumers are trading safety for convenience and efficiency. They're saying, in effect, the reward is worth the risk. If cyberattacks become much more common, they may change their minds.

Some cybersecurity experts think safety can be boosted without disconnecting. One example: Businesses should separate their administrative and operational networks so that a breach in the former doesn't make the latter vulnerable. Another example: Much stronger passwords and strict encryption.

Won't quantum computers eventually be able to decrypt anything? The experts have apparently seen this coming and have worked for years to develop quantum-resistant encryption. Banks, among others, are said to be putting it into place now even though a threat from quantum computers is likely years away.

The world is a risky place. People learn to live with some risks. Can we learn to live with the risks of being online that AI has made increasingly clear? That's a question yet to be answered.

Urban Lehner can be reached at urbanize@gmail.com

P[] D[728x170] M[320x75] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]
P[L2] D[728x90] M[320x50] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]

Comments

To comment, please Log In or Join our Community .