Letters to the Editor

We're Adapting Our Farm to Changing Weather. Crop Insurance Is Holding Us Back.

The views expressed are those of the individual authors and not necessarily those of DTN, its management or employees.

**

To the Editor:

Our fourth-generation family farm in Lapwai, Idaho, is facing increasingly extreme weather that presents new risks to our operation. Every year we make decisions about what to plant while considering how much rain to expect and how to manage rising input costs. As our weather grows more volatile and water becomes scarcer, those decisions look different than they used to.

In today's farm economy, we have no choice but to adapt. But here's the catch: Some farming changes that make our operation more resilient to weather volatility, water scarcity and input cost fluctuations introduce new risks that crop insurance isn't designed to handle.

P[L1] D[0x0] M[300x250] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]

Throughout our farm's 100-year history, flexible crop rotations have served as one of our best risk-management tools. In any given year, our rotation can include wheat, barley, oats, peas, lentils, chickpeas, canola, mustard, flax and other crops. For decades, we've used diverse rotations and no-till farming to protect our soil and strengthen the resilience of our business. That flexibility matters even more as climatic and economic pressures mount. A safety net that gives us freedom to experiment with production practices that can boost our resilience is what we need to adapt.

We have a long history of using federal crop insurance to protect our business against yield and revenue losses that could threaten our economic viability. Over the years, our family could point to moments when insurance kept the lights on following extreme weather events. Unfortunately, we're finding each time we renew our insurance, this vital safety net isn't keeping up with our farming adaptations.

Here's a recent example from our farm. We intercropped winter green peas with rapeseed last year, because we've seen crops like rapeseed help pea crops stand up better, resist disease and benefit the winter wheat that follows. But because the peas were intercropped, they were uninsurable under federal crop insurance rules.

Then came a particularly cold, wet winter. Disease wiped out the entire pea crop, along with the neighboring pea field that wasn't intercropped. The intercrop didn't cause that loss; the weather did. We absorbed all of it.

The risk didn't end there. That field was then classified as a "failed crop," meaning we couldn't insure the winter canola that followed, even though the failed peas had never been insured in the first place. One year of innovation, two years of risk exposure.

It's frustrating, but we've accepted some of that risk as the price of progress. But as margins tighten, we're having to ask whether we can afford to keep being penalized for innovating, even though it will lead to greater resilience in the long term.

Now, multiply this by decisions being made by other farmers across the country. While our farm decided to take on the risk of innovation, many farmers across the country can't afford to.

The challenge is that the Federal Crop Insurance Program was largely built around established crops, conventional practices and historical production records. Many farmers are now facing conditions that are changing quickly, and the insurance system isn't keeping up. The answer isn't for farmers to stop innovating. It's to modernize crop insurance.

Workarounds exist, such as written agreements that allow USDA's Risk Management Agency (RMA) to approve coverage for crops or practices outside standard policies, like continuous-crop winter canola. But the process is cumbersome, coverage is limited, and case-by-case exceptions can't keep pace with innovation on the farm.

Fortunately, promising solutions are emerging. Insurers, farmers, researchers and technology providers are already exploring ways to use better data, crop models and new insurance structures to cover emerging crops and practices, recognize risk-reducing production methods and respond more quickly when losses occur.

One promising example is the recently announced NextGen Crop Insurance Pilot in Michigan, developed by a coalition of agriculture, finance and conservation groups with the insurance brokerage firm Aon and funded by the Michigan Department of Agriculture and Rural Development. The program aims to offer adjusted crop insurance rates based on field-level risk and the risk-reduction impact of soil health practices. It's limited to corn and soybeans in four Michigan counties, but it shows what's possible. Idaho's wheat, pulse and oilseed growers need something like it, too.

Innovations like this shouldn't be a rare exception. Private insurers, researchers and farm groups are ready to bring new ideas forward, and the RMA has the authority to approve them. What's missing is a pathway that can keep up with the rate of changing farm practices. Greater public-private innovation partnership can harness the innovation and speed of the private sector and the scale and funding support of the public sector. Congress should give RMA direction and resources to fast-track promising pilots and keep coverage evolving as agriculture does. Farmers adapt season by season. Crop insurance needs to keep up.

The question is not whether we will have to adapt. We already are. The question is whether our insurance system will slow us down or help us go faster.

-- Cori Wittman Stitt, CEO and CFO of Wittman Farms, a family-owned crop, cattle and timber operation in Lapwai, Idaho, and a member of Environmental Defense Fund's farmer advisory network

P[] D[728x170] M[320x75] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]
P[L1] D[728x90] M[320x50] OOP[F] ADUNIT[] T[]