Farm Show Finds

Transportation Time Bomb

Mary Kennedy
By  Mary Kennedy , DTN Basis Analyst
Connect with Mary:
Locks are among U.S. transportation infrastructure categories overdue for needed updates, Image by Getty Images

The Soy Transportation Coalition (STC) noted in a recent press release there was “widespread agreement that it is not a matter of if there will be a failure at one or more of our key lock and dam sites, it is a matter of when.

“A failure of significant duration--particularly during and subsequent to harvest--would severely impact the competitiveness of the soybean and grain industries and diminish the profitability of the individual farmer,” it explains. “This increasingly likely scenario must be avoided. As a result, an enhanced focus on operations and maintenance to increase the reliability of resiliency of the nation’s locks and dams should be adopted.”

The STC went on to recommend that “available funding for new construction of locks and dams should be directed first to locks and dams 20 to 25 on the Mississippi River.”

There are currently 28 locks and dams on the Upper Mississippi River system. They are operated by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and also maintains a 9-foot channel on the Mississippi River, from St. Paul, Minnesota, to St. Louis. As the aging locks and dams continue to deteriorate, especially when damaged by floods, the Corps has to make costly repairs and, in some cases, can only make a temporary fix.

The USACE has said in the past it is “unable to adequately fund maintenance activities to ensure the navigation system operates at an acceptable level of performance.”

DISRUPTIONS. The most notable disruption last fall was the multiple closures between September and October at locks and dams 52 and 53 on the Ohio River. These disruptions occurred at the worst time for farmers, who were hauling their fall harvest to the river for shipment to the Gulf of Mexico. Even though the river finally reopened there on Oct. 19, the backlog of tows remained an issue well into November, slowing traffic anxious to get to the Gulf for export. Problems continued into January 2018, stalling barges at times from getting up- and downriver.

In May 2017, USACE, Rock Island District, reported there were structural concerns on the downstream guide wall at locks and dams 52 and 53 on the Ohio River, and Dam 15 in Rock Island, Illinois. Aaron Dunlop, operations project manager for the Rock Island District’s Mississippi River Project, said in a press release four monoliths (a large, single, upright block of stone) making up a portion of the guide wall had to be demolished as the failing concrete was creating risk to the navigation system.

“The lower 120 feet of the guide wall is structurally failing, which could result in it falling into the navigation channel,” Dunlop says. “If it were to fall into the channel, this would block navigation for nearly a month, as crews would need to respond to remove the broken concrete blocking access to the lock chamber.”

OVERDUE. The section of guide wall demolished was original to the project. Lock and Dam 15 was the first lock completed on the Upper Mississippi River as part of the 9-foot navigation system. Construction at Lock and Dam 15 finished in 1934. The intended design life of the lock was about 50 years, according to the USACE.

Mike Cox, chief of the Rock Island District Operations Division, says locks such as those at Lock and Dam 15 have outlived their design life because of adaptive maintenance and periodic major rehabilitation. “The concrete issue on the lock’s lower guide wall is indicative of infrastructure that is well past its prime,” Cox says.

Guide walls are integral to each of the Mississippi River Locks and Dams 2 through 10, the USACE says. Guide walls are long extensions of the lock walls, in either the upstream or downstream direction, that are parallel to the lock wall. These walls serve primarily to guide the long tows into the lock and to provide mooring facilities for tows too long to be accommodated in a single lockage.

“Almost all of the locks and dams on the Upper Mississippi River System, including the Illinois Waterway, are experiencing varying levels of problems due to the age of the infrastructure,” Cox says. “The teams do a great job of ensuring that critical maintenance is performed, which they have to this point, preventing a catastrophic failure of the system.” The locks and dams are critical to the nation’s economy as they provide the most efficient method to transport goods and commodities.”

WHITE HOUSE PLEDGE. President Donald Trump noted in his State of the Union address he will approve funding of $1.5 trillion for the rebuilding of bridges, highways, locks and dams, airports and other projects. The question remains as to whether infrastructure funding will be approved.

“We are still anxious to see greater specificity--particularly regarding funding--from the White House and Congress on an infrastructure strategy,” points out Mike Steenhoek, executive director of the STC. “Funding remains the main obstacle to seeing an infrastructure package transition from an intention to an outcome. As the weeks progress, we anticipate a more specific set of recommendations from the White House and Congress. We look forward to being engaged in this process.”

In a Jan. 3, 2018, Washington Post article, President Trump said: “Infrastructure is by far the easiest,” during the bill signing for the tax overhaul. “People want it--Republicans and Democrats. We’re going to have tremendous Democrat support on infrastructure as you know. I could’ve started with infrastructure--I actually wanted to save the easy one for the one down the road. So, we’ll be having that done pretty quickly.”

Cox hints that if it’s such an easy fix, the government best hurry and get something done. “Most of our system represents a single point of failure, because there is only one lock chamber at most sites. So, if one lock experiences a failure, the whole navigation system would likely shut down, which would come with a high cost,” Cox says.


Past Issues