An Urban's Rural View

No, It's Not the Equivalent of the Flu -- Yet

Urban C Lehner
By  Urban C Lehner , Editor Emeritus
Connect with Urban:
Drive-up vaccinations were recently done in Brenham, Texas. The leading vaccines have proved in trials to be extraordinarily effective at preventing death from COVID-19. (Photo by Elaine Thomas)

A year ago, as America was just being introduced to COVID-19, people I respect were predicting it would be no worse than the flu.

There are still a few people saying that but it's hard to respect what they say. The epidemic has now taken more than 450,000 American lives, more than 10 times the flu's annual toll. As many Americans have died of COVID-19 as were killed in World War II and the Korean War combined.

Yet if it's wrong to equate COVID-19 and the flu today, there are signs it could be right in the foreseeable future. Thanks to the rollout of vaccines, it seems possible that within the next year or two, COVID-19 could be reduced to the point where it poses no more terrors than influenza.

Today, with fewer than 10% of Americans vaccinated, new and highly transmissible variants of COVID-19 are spreading. Some experts think the worst of the epidemic is still ahead of us.

But as more of us are vaccinated, today's pain could turn into long-term gain. At flu-like rates, deaths from COVID-19 would decline dramatically.

Some people would still die. Influenza claims 20,000, 30,000, sometimes even 40,000 lives a year. But even in bad years, flu doesn't rank among the top 10 causes of death in the U.S. (https://www.cdc.gov/…) At 450,000-plus, COVID-19 is currently the third-leading cause of death, behind heart disease and cancer.

The hopeful point is that the leading vaccines have proved in trials to be extraordinarily effective at preventing death. For example, none of the people who received the Moderna vaccine in its trial developed COVID-19 symptoms and none died. In the control group, the people given the placebo, 30 came down with severe cases and one died. (https://www.sciencemag.org/…)

This holds out hope that in the future, COVID-19 deaths will occur overwhelmingly among those who weren't vaccinated. As it becomes clear that vaccinated people rarely die, resistance to the vaccines should diminish. If this sounds outlandishly optimistic, that may be because you've read that the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines are only about 95% effective. What 95% refers to, though, is how effective the vaccines were at preventing the disease. For preventing deaths, the effective rate in the trials was 100%.

Many long months will pass before deaths come down to flu levels. Yes, the vaccine rollout is accelerating, but COVID-19's mutations are accelerating, too. Some experts think the UK variant is 50% more transmissible and will in March become the dominant strand of the disease in the U.S. (https://www.propublica.org/…)

And the UK variant itself is mutating, as South Africa has discovered to its displeasure. In Brazil, another mutation has brought a surge of cases to Manaus, a city where 75% of the population had previously been infected by COVID. (https://www.npr.org/…)

With variants starting to show up in the U.S., we all need to double down on masking, social distancing and hand washing. To give the medical system a better shot at countering the variants, the government needs to do more genome sequencing.

"We don't know how many variants are in the United States or how widespread they are, and we don't have a rapid-response system to evaluate the effectiveness of the available vaccines and treatments against them," said a group of advisors to the president's transition team. They recommend sequencing 50,000 cases a week, with a focus on those who are infected after being vaccinated or having previously been infected. (https://www.washingtonpost.com/…) The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention currently has contracts to sequence only 6,000 samples a week. (https://www.cdc.gov/…)

Yet if the present is scary, the vaccines offer promise for the future. And three new vaccines are on the way. That means more people will be vaccinated sooner rather than later.

Johnson & Johnson just asked for emergency authorization for its vaccine and promised to deliver 100 million doses in this year's first half. This one-shot vaccine is less effective in preventing the disease than Moderna or Pfizer but no one who has received it in trials has been hospitalized or died -- even in South Africa, where that troublesome mutation of the coronavirus originated. (https://www.washingtonpost.com/…) and (https://www.washingtonpost.com/…)

COVID-19 isn't going away, probably ever. But if vaccines can turn it into another flu, life really can return to something approaching normal. If the vaccines prove in practice as effective in preventing death as they did in the trials, there will be renewed respect for the view that COVID-19 is no worse than the flu.

Urban Lehner can be reached at urbanize@gmail.com

Comments

To comment, please Log In or Join our Community .

Urban Lehner
2/12/2021 | 7:25 AM CST
Thanks. If you're looking at this by state, you have to adjust for population size. On the basis of a total deaths per 100,000 of population since late January of 2020, the worst states are Alabama, South Dakota, New Jersey, Connecticut and Massachusttes. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#cases_deathsper100k
grnpaint
2/11/2021 | 12:57 PM CST
Why don't you get off the media bandwagon. 56 percent of the deaths are in these 5 states, New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Michigan andPennsylvania. They have only 19 percent of the population in the USA. This statistically is way outside a normal bell curve, why do you suppose this is?
Urban Lehner
2/11/2021 | 8:33 AM CST
Thanks for your comment. CDC has a variety of numbers, the lowest of which is 421,000 and the highest 569,000. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/covid19/mortality-overview.htm. The compilations done by various news agencies based on reports from state governments are putting the number at 473,000.
TRKCHILD@MAC.COM
2/10/2021 | 10:28 PM CST
Have you looked at the CDC data on year on year deaths? The numbers the CDC is showing do not support this theory of 450,000 deaths.